Lucas Hinderlighter on Kill Tony

Bucket PullYoungBig Joke Book

2 sets·2.00 bits/set·2.50 beats/set·0.44 punch density·2.00 tag density

About Lucas Hinderlighter's sets

Lucas Hinderlighter has done 2 sets on Kill Tony, the first on episode #719 (20 May 2025) and the latest on episode #768 (19 May 2026).

Lucas Hinderlighter came to the show as a bucket pull, a comic whose name is drawn from the bucket for a one-minute set.

Lucas Hinderlighter has performed for guest panels including Shane Gillis, James Mccann and Harland Williams.

Lucas Hinderlighter averages 0.44 laugh lines, punchlines and tags, for every setup or filler line. That is more than 59% of the 1,713 other comics PunchNotes has broken down.

On average Lucas Hinderlighter follows each punchline with 2.00 tags.

Of the 5 jokes PunchNotes has classified, 3 are misdirect jokes, ahead of reframe (1).

Appearances

EpisodeDateGuest panelBitsPunch densityTag density
KT #768Big Joke Book19 May 2026Shane Gillis, James Mccann20.401.00
KT #719Big Joke Book20 May 2025Harland Williams20.473.00

Jokes from Lucas Hinderlighter's sets

A few jokes from each set. Open a set for the full transcript and every joke.

KT #76819 May 2026

reframe
setup

I had a weird day today. I walked into a porta potty that didn't have any toilet paper in it.

punchline

So I walked out of that porta potty wearing only one sock.

tag

Yeah, yeah, because I had to wipe with the rest of my clothes.

double-meaning
setup

I found a box in his room that was labeled "The Barely Legal Porn." Now, in 2026, barely legal porn is 18-year-old girls.

punchline

But my grandpa's so old that it was all just interracial.

KT #71920 May 2025

misdirect
setup

And it was cool, you know, we had a good relationship. I will say the hardest part about dating a they/them is we would get into arguments

punchline

and I didn't know if I could hit them.

tag

Yeah, like tell me which one you are.

tag

Are you a boy or a girl?

misdirect
setup

"that's a pretty German name. "Sounds like a Nazi's name." Yeah, and that's when I tell them it was actually.

punchline

My grandpa.

Lucas Hinderlighter on Kill Tony: 2 Sets and Jokes | PunchNotes